Why are communists popular in West Bengal and Kerala ?
Posted by barunroy on July 8, 2008
THROUGH COMMENT AT BEACON ONLINE
By Sumita Ghosh
Inspite of economic policies that have destroyed industry in the two states , leaving the populations with no choice but to migrate to other states or out of the country to earn a livelihood , communists still win every election. In West Bengal in particular , the communists are breaking all sort of records and even demolishing the dreaded incumbency syndrome by winning all elections held over the last 3 decades.
I have never been to West Bengal , but saw a BBC program which focussed on the rural areas just a few miles away from Kolkata , the poverty of the people was heartbreaking. Also seen pictures of people in rural Bengal living on the brink of starvation. Massive proportion of the population of Bengal lives well under the poverty line. Closer to Bihar than the rest of India. Other poor states like Rajasthan , MP and even UP have shown remarkable improvement in eradicating poverty to an extent over the recent past, but Bengal has been a huge failure on this front.
Heard gory stories of a Mamta Banerjee led Trinamul Congress supporter having his hands cut off by leftist goondas. Also of stories of massive petty corruption in railways , where a naive TC gets getting beaten out of his life if he demands certain passengers to show their tickets. Muslim dominated colonies that get free electricity and never have to pay any bill of any sort. Married hindu women who get molested at will by the leftist and muslim goons and police and public simply looks the other way.
Managers of factories and tea plantations who get burnt alive in their office by labor trade union members. 90% (just a guess) of factories closed down as a result of militant leftist trade unionism , which basically demands all pay and no work as a fundamental right.
Recently by opposing the US-India defence partnership and organising massive protests against the joint air exercises conducted by the air forces of the two countries in West Bengal , the communists have shown their intent to target India’s vital strategic interests and relationships. So much hatred for US is inexplicable when US is giving India its hand in friendship and emerged as India’s most important trading partner. The communists never protest so much when Chinese or Pakistani head of states visit India….neither have they ever raised a voice in support of the Kashmiri Pandits who were ethnically cleansed from the Kashmir Valley. Worse – I have read reports from a leftist columnist shedding tears over the (muslim) Kashmiris , deamding their right for self-determination and contemptuously referring to our brave Indian soldiers as ‘goondas’ and ‘rapists’.
Muslim fundamentalism and separatism has already peaked in both states and is a huge risk to India’s national security and territorial integrity. But the biggest shame is how this serious problem – a demographic war declared by muslims on India not only gets a wink from the ruling leftist government (or the equally culpable ruling Congress govt. in Kerala) , but is infact actively encouraged – because of the massive muslim vote blocks consituted by the massive influx from Bangladesh. An asset during election time.
In Kerala , muslims return from a sojurn in the Gulf , many newly converted to the fanatical cult of Wahabbi Islam , turning otherwise ordinary men into fervent anti-national terrorists , bent upon creating a dar-ul-islam (Nation of Islam) out of dar-ul-harb (Nation of War).
These are massive problems that we as Indians have to contend with. The recent furore over the Ganguly issue in West Bengal shows how far removed from reality our people are in that state. Reflects poorly on their sense of priorities. Their state is under attack. Our nation is under attack. Our collective survival depends on how fast we recognise this threat and fight back. First step towards that goal is to exercise our democratic right and vote out the anti-national communists.
Relay said
the writer of this article admits :
“I have never been to West Bengal , but saw a BBC program ” !!
this seems to be an article written by someone who has no first hand experience on the subject matter. Seems to have been ordered to write it by turncoat Gurkha sympathizers to embarrass those who oppose Gurkhaland.
But TWO WRONGS SELDOM MAKE A RIGHT.
CP-M rule of W. Bengal has been disastrous but that does not give the Nepali Gurkha ILLEGALS of Darjeeling any right to demand Gurkhaland.
If you don’t like it here in WB anymore then JUST GO BACK TO NEPAL
and don’t forget to take with you all the kids that you have produced like rabbits while in India.
aniramzee said
He may have never been to West Bengal but he doesn’t need to have gone there to get an understanding of the situation.Don’t you understand what’s going on in Israel and the US just by watching TV?And I don’t support the Gurkhaland state either.They can demand equal rights, and that should be provided.This can be done only if the goons are ousted from Bengal.Creating a new state for every social group which has a problem with the administrative will result in India being divided into 543 states.
It is because of the Gurkha insurgents,the Assam and other north-eastern state insurgents that those parts have seen no development.If the communists are a burden to India,so are the Gurkhas.They need to go about in a different style.
Asking for their language to be taught in schools,making sure their people get jobs is a good thing.Making a new state is definitely not a soultion.
JTM said
Todays HT carries an article on Buddhadeb the CM, having ordered the police firing at Nandigram on March 14,2007. Chheee Chheee. Naam Buddha deb aur kaam hinsak. If Gurung was’nt there standing solidly in Darjeeling, god knows how many firings he would ordered on the people like the police atrocities in Silguri. When he can kill his own plainspeople what are the poor hill people?
DB said
Buddhadeb has now been proved “Abuddhadeb” for killing the citizens of India! He is now proved a mass murderer and a terrorist.
Any law that can prosecute people in power in India?
DB said
Buddha ordered firing in Nandigram: Forward Bloc
ZeeNews, Kolkata, April 20: In what might come as an embarrassment to the Left Front government ahead of the Lok Sabha election, key Front partner Forward Bloc on Monday said that Chief Minister Buddhadeb Bhattacharjee had ordered the police firing in Nandigram in March, 2007.
“I had asked Bhattacharjee in a Left Front meeting who had ordered the firing in Nandigram and the Chief Minister took upon himself the responsibility and replied it was he who ordered it. Bhattacharjee also admitted that it was a mistake,” veteran Forward Bloc leader Ashok Ghose told a meet-the-press programme here.
Ghose, also the state secretary of the party, said, however, that the Left’s poll prospects in the state would not be hampered by admitting its mistakes.
“We fight election depending on our organisation. No one has the strength to stand before our booth committees,” he asserted.
Sticking to his earlier stand that the police firing in Nandigram was unjust and it was wrong to acquire multi-crop land in Singur for Tata Motors’ Nano project, Ghose said there would not have been any problem if the Nano project was shifted to West Midnapore.
The Bloc leader said he had suggested that a law be enacted to determine the process of land acquisition and rehabilitation package.
To a question, the veteran leader said it would be a tough electoral battle in the Lok Sabha poll, but “earlier also the Left had faced such a challenge in 1977.”
He said that there was disunity among LF partners in last year’s panchayat election which had helped the Opposition to gain some ground.
DB said
Nandigram
The controversy over the state government plan to build a chemical hub in Nandigram led opposition parties to organise against the acquisition of land. The Trinamool Congress, Socialist Unity Centre of India (SUCI), Jamiat Ulema-e-Hind and Indian National Congress cooperated to establish the Bhumi Uchhed Pratirodh Committee (‘Committee Against Land Evictions’). A large number of erstwhile supporters of the ruling CPI(M) party also joined them. The apparent aim of the BUPC was to protect the farmers’ lands. However the top leadership of the ruling party, determined to ride roughshod over all opposition, painted the agitation as one against industrialisation. The official propaganda by carried by pro-government media talked of jobs for the large number of unemployed youths of the state of West Bengal and made claims of a boost to development in the area. According to the version propagated by the party, the region would have become an industrial belt and would have attracted further investments and jobs to the state. The main opposition party, the TMC, maintains however that they are opposed not to industrialization per se but poorly planned projects carried out with inhuman methods.
The situation came to a head when the MP from nearby Haldia took a pro-active role in the project. The Haldia Development Authority under him issued a notice for land acquisition. Several supporters of both the CPI(M) and the BUPC were violently attacked by opponents with their houses vandalised. Both sides amassed huge quatities of arms and several clashes resulted in incidents allegedly of arson, murder and rape. However, the BUPC got the upper hand owing to its commanding greater public support and allegedly supported by Maoists, did not allow police and CPI(M) cadre to enter for over 3 months by digging up roads.
When the ruling party sought to reestablish its previous domination, it mobilised the administration in the name of removing blockades and restoring “normalcy”. On the night of March 14, 2007, the party’s cadre allegedly bolstered by “hired hardened criminals from the state and outside”, conducted a joint operation with the state police. They unleashed a reign of terror, killing people, maiming many more and allegedly committing numerous infanticides and rapes. There were allegations of removal of evidence in the form of dead bodies and injured persons. Several writers, artists, poets and academicians took a strong position against the police firing which in turn brought significant international attention.